All of the votes haven’t been counted yet but it seems pretty safe to say that Gavin Newsom is going to survive the recall.
Am I disappointed? Of course. I can’t stand Gavin Newsom and it’s hard for me to understand people who do. Anyone who is serious about getting people vaccinated or masked should resent a politician like Gavin Newsom, one who can’t even follow the same rules that he imposes on everyone else.
Am I surprised? Not really. There was a point when the Republicans could have defeated Newsom but they didn’t take advantage of the moment. Instead of duplicating Schwarzenegger’s strategy of trying to appeal to all voters, Larry Elder concentrated only on Republican voters. You’re not going to win in a deep blue state like California by only trying to appeal to hardcore Republicans because there’s just not enough of them to swing the election. Newsom was able to shift the focus away from his own failings as governor and California’s naturally blue tint carried him to victory.
From the point of view of someone who enjoys following politics, an upset victory is always more interesting than a predictable win, which is why it was enjoyable to fantasize about the media freakout if Newsom had been recalled. (Also, I’d be lying if I said that nostalgia for the truly wild 2003 California recall wasn’t a factor when it came to my interesting in the current rcall.) In this time of intense polarization, it seems more likely that unexpected victories are going to become something that happens in primaries but not general elections.
Newsom survived so expect to hear a lot of talk about how this proves Biden is more popular than people realize. It’s like when the Republicans convince themselves that Ossoff losing a House race meant that 2018 wasn’t going to be as bad as everyone thought it was going to be. That’s the general rule of politics in the 21st Century. Elections only matter when your side wins.