I’m like a lot of people, in that I was dreading the Raphael Warnock/Herschel Walker debate but it turns out that rumors of Walker’s incompetence as a candidate were exaggerated. In fact, after watching the debate, it’s pretty clear that Walker won the debate.
Some of that is Warnock’s fault. Watching the debate, I got the feeling that Warnock assumed that he would so easily walk over Walker that he could get away with not adequately preparing. Warnock is definitely the more polished candidate but he was almost too polished. His answers felt rehearsed, in much the same way that Tim Kaine’s answer felt pre-written in his only 2016 debate with Mike Pence. (Picking Tim Kaine for her running mate, instead of Cory Booker or even Julian Castro, was one of Hillary Clinton’s biggest mistakes.)
As for Walker, he came across as someone who might not be a smooth politician but who actually cared about the election and who was willing to do the work necessary to make his arguments. Warnock seemed to take it for granted that he would win just be showing up. Walker proved him wrong.
It really all came down to hubris. That’s been the biggest issue for the Democrats ever since Biden was elected. They’ve been so convinced that the Republicans will self-destruct that they never bothered to come up with a Plan B. It reminds me of what I saw during the 2020 elections in Texas. The Democrats running for Congress and the State Legislature were so convinced, due to the results of 2018, that they were going to win that few of them bothered to start paying attention to what the voters wanted until the last two weeks of the campaign. Suddenly, candidates who had been bragging about their efforts to defund the police suddenly started running tough-on-crime ads. It didn’t fool anyone.
Is Walker going to be elected? I don’t know. But he’s a far stronger candidate than many are willing to admit. Imagine if this race goes to a run-off and the Senate majority is hanging in the balance. If that’s the case, I feel for the poor people of Georgia, having to deal with all of this for an extra month.