I know some people are surprised that the House Democratic Caucus went ahead and selected Nancy Pelosi for Speaker again but really, what else could they do? No one else was stepping up to challenge her for the job and the Democrats are not going to publicly rebuke the first women to ever serve as Speaker of the House.
The only way that the Democrats would have dumped Pelosi would have been if another potentially history-making candidate had stepped up to challenge her, someone like Karen Bass or Hakeem Jeffries or Marcia Fudge or even James Clyburn. Even then, I think they would have attempted to keep the negotiations private, with Pelosi voluntarily retiring if she saw evidence that she didn’t have the votes. However, Jeffries endorsed Pelosi early on and James Clyburn currently has so much influence with Joe Biden that becoming Speaker would almost be a step down for him. Karen Bass, meanwhile, stands a pretty good chance of being appointed to the U.S. Senate after Kamala Harris resigns her seat to become vice president.
With no one stepping up to challenge her, Pelosi has been reelected. I think the Democrats would be better off with a different, younger leader but that’s not going to happen this Congress.
(For the record, when she was challenged by a Seth Moulton-led attempt to bring in a younger leadership team in 2019, Pelosi did say that she would step down as Speaker after the 2022 midterms, regardless of which party won control of the chamber. Whether or not she’ll keep her word is anyone’s guess.)